The Z4 Everyone Argued About Is Now 22 Years Old, and This One-Owner 2004 2.5i Has Just 21,600 Miles

Elizabeth Puckett Elizabeth Puckett |
— 2 min read
| Add Motorious
Titanium Silver 2004 BMW Z4 2.5i roadster with a red interior

The collector car market, in your inbox

Classic car news, hand-picked vehicles, and auction coverage. Choose what lands in your inbox.

A 2004 BMW Z4 2.5i is live on Hagerty Marketplace in Farmington, Connecticut, with a high bid of $3,000 after two bids at the time of writing. The auction is scheduled to end at 3:35 p.m. ET on Monday, Nov. 30. The roadster shows 21,600 miles, which works out to fewer than 1,000 a year over 22 years, and it comes with its original window sticker and paperwork.

The BMW everyone argued about

When the E85-generation Z4 arrived for 2003 as the replacement for the Z3, it did not ease into the market. Designer Anders Warming's creased, sculpted bodywork came out of BMW's "flame surfacing" era, and the reaction was split. One Australian launch review listed the styling as polarizing and the steering as a point of contention, while a PistonHeads writer later defended the design as one of the better results of that period. The car was built at BMW's plant in Spartanburg, South Carolina.

The spec enthusiasts usually skip

This is the entry-level version. The 2.5i uses a 2.5-liter inline-six rated at 184 horsepower, and this car pairs it with the five-speed Steptronic automatic rather than the manual. For a roadster sold on driving feel, that is the transmission many enthusiasts would pass over, which is part of what makes a well-kept example interesting.

According to the listing, the window sticker shows the Premium Package, which adds a fully automatic power soft top, power seats with driver memory and leather upholstery. The car also has wood trim, heated front seats and fog lights on 16-inch alloy wheels. It is finished in Titanium Silver Metallic over a Dream Red and black leather interior.

History and condition

The listing says the Z4 was originally delivered to BMW of Manhattan and stayed with its first owner until the selling dealer acquired it recently. The dealer calls it "exceptional condition" and lists a clean CARFAX Vehicle History Report, a clean Connecticut title, the window sticker, the owner's manuals and manufacturer's literature. Recent dealer service includes an oil change, fuel system cleaning, brake fluid flush, new air and cabin filters and a safety inspection.

Not everything is showroom-fresh. The listing discloses wear on the seat upholstery, and the Bridgestone tires carry 2015 date codes, so they are more than a decade old and would be a first priority for any buyer planning to drive the car. Hagerty notes that listing details come from the seller and that bidders are responsible for their own due diligence, so the 167-photo gallery and the walkaround video added on Nov. 18 are a sensible place to start.

Why it deserves a second look

A base 2.5i with an automatic is not the Z4 enthusiasts tend to chase, and that is part of the appeal. A car that has averaged under 1,000 miles a year for 22 years, with its window sticker and books still with it, makes a good case for preserving something that was never the obvious choice. The listing makes no claims about value, and neither do we. The more interesting question is what makes a car worth keeping when nobody was sure about it to begin with.

For more overlooked roadsters and low-mile BMWs, see our looks at a 16k-mile 1998 BMW 318i, a 2007 Saturn Sky Red Line and an 18k-mile Cadillac XLR.

The auction ends Monday, Nov. 30, at 3:35 p.m. ET. See the full photo gallery and bid history on Hagerty Marketplace.

Great! Next, complete checkout for full access to Motorious.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to Motorious.
Success! Your account is fully activated, you now have access to all content.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.